mahogany vs spruce top

The coupling of a spruce top with rosewood or mahogany back and sides is a tough combination to beat, because the results consistently sound so good. Spruce vs Mahogany for top I assume this is for an acoustic guitar: Usually one would only consider mahogany for the back and sides, not the top of a guitar. Show Printable Version; Feb-07-2006, 10:22am #1. Many refer to mahogany as having a “darker” tone, but such descriptions are misleading and can oversimplify a varied and complex issue. All mahogany vs. mahogany with spruce top. This, of course, as always, depends on your particular tastes – mostly. Feb 26, 2020 #3 I agree with howthewestwas1's assessment. I have an all mahogany Martin 000-15S. So, what a great way to test between a guitar with a mahogany top and a spruce top. So, in the battle of Sapele vs Mahogany, which is the better tonewood? Go. Though Ibanez may not be the first brand that comes to an acoustic guitarist’s mind when shopping for a dreadnought, the AVD60NT, which has a torrefied (they call it “thermo aged”) Adirondack spruce top and spruce braces, delivered straight-up mahogany dreadnought tone. rowdyyates. 1; 2; First Prev 2 of 2 Go to page. I'm pretty sure I'm going to buy a Mid-Mo as my first mandolin. I personally enjoy rosewood guitars, but if I were buying a J45 I think I would opt for a mahogany model with a pickup. Would my rosewood fingerboard vs. the GS Mini's ebony fingerboard make a lot difference in this regard? The Things that Are the Same. It doesn't hurt to have one of everything. Featuring a solid Sitka spruce top, the AJ-220S kicks out outstanding defined, detailed tone. Play a well opened up Martin D-28 or Guild D50, and you'll see what I mean. View Profile View Forum Posts View Blog Entries View Articles Registered User Join Date Dec 2004 Location Long Island, NY, USA Posts 4,058. It was widely used on pre-war and vintage instruments. Given how a mahogany top sounds softer and rounder, would this suffer the same (or worse) fate as my current solid spruce top dreadnaught, or do solid mahogany tops retain much clarity even when the strings have some age? References. New mother-of-pearl pattern inlay on the rosette and fingerboard lend a richness to the D-X2E Mahogany making it as impressive to look at as it is to play. Will Ramsey wrote for Hoover’s Online beginning in 1997. Mahogany or cedar may have a nice tone for mild playing, but I've never played any guitar with a mahogany or cedar top that had any kind of "headroom". It should also be noted that Sapele on one guitar (with different materials and construction) will sound different to Sapele on another – and the same goes for Mahogany. Mahogany For The Top, Back, and Sides Of a Guitar. View Profile View Forum Posts Private Message Visit Homepage Senior Member Join … Reactions: Don A, Thumpalumpacus, Peanut73 and 4 others. For some musicians, the sound it produces is a clearer, balanced, and more sustained. All very impressive, but what does it mean? Wow this one looks very sharp! The mahogany back and sides complement the spruce top, adding a slightly lower tone to the spruce's midrange. Silver Supporting Member. What is the Difference Between Sapele and Mahogany. Messages 5,549 . Messages 748. There's a few nice Collings OM's and 0's around at decent used prices. In general terms, mahogany is clear and rosewood is dark. Tonally, it has far warmer, darker tone than both Cedar and Spruce. Successful sellers: Nuprin (Mele Tenor Koa/Mahogany Electric on 11/2009) Successful buyers: Tomdini (Pono Tenor Mango Cutaway Electric on 10/2009) 07-13-2008, 02:52 PM #7. uke142464 . Cedar is softer wood, which sounds more mellow, but is more prone to scratches because cedar tops usually have a satin finish instead of high gloss. Spruce top. Since then I’ve bought a Stagg solid mahogany top/back and sides soprano which has a lovely warm sound even now and in 6-12 months will sound even be better. Of course, spruce has a pretty distinct sound-- people often compare it to a Spanish guitar. Spruce top guitars vary in the quality of tone they produce. Mahogany tops are … I am a fingerpicker and curious about the tonal aspects of these woods. mahogany vs. rosewood General Acoustic Guitar Discussion The Acoustic Guitar ... whats the general opinion on solid mahogany b/s versus solid rosewood b/s on a spruce top guitar. The sapele version we bought unheard from an online picture but based on the evenness and uniformity of the grain pattern pictured in the stores ad (we got the guitar pictured). However, other options arguably have more visual appeal: North American flame maple, for instance, as well as figured ash, bubinga, and the following “exotics.” Exotics. One person suggested you try for a model with a red spruce top. Spruce top on Mid-Mo. >>Learn more about tonewood characteristics here. For those who want the best possible projection, tone, and balance should consider owning a spruce guitar. The top of the guitar vibrates and produces the sound so the tradition has been that this wood is a softer wood, usually spruce or cedar. For example, when mahogany wood is used on the top of a guitar, it produces a rich, smooth, and warm sound with subtle undertones. Most archtop guitars have spruce tops, so let’s consider what a spruce-topped archtop can sound like when combined with maple or mahogany. Adirondack has a crisp, clear tone with high headroom and strong fundamental content. Thread: Mahogany vs. Available in soprano, concert, tenor, and baritone models—tenor also available with electronics and a … With that being said, I think you're right in that we get into subjective territory … Is is combined with laminates? So it's a "better" instrument in that way. I think of them like coffee - rosewood is the espresso and mahogany is the cafe americano. Adirondack Red Spruce. Mahogany is a dense wood, with a dark finish, and close grain. For example it can sometimes be paired with Sitka Spruce – this pairing can mellow out the sound of the spruce a bit and beef up the mid-range, add a more beefy character and reduce overtones. Sound Produced by Cedar. Even though I like my spruce-top, I intend to get a mahogany soon enough. Re: all mahogany vs. spruce/mahogany guitar « Reply #11 on: January 31, 2012, 08:40:54 PM » I have an 2005 512ce-L10 (all hog), and it has fantastic tone across the full range. Compared to a spruce top, a mahogany top tends to have warmer and rounded top end and a generally more mellow and less immediate sound. This Dreadnought sized model has a Sitka spruce top and figured mahogany pattern high-pressure laminate (HPL) back and sides. Folks on a budget can find a relatively good-sounding spruce top guitar at an affordable price if they shop around. Mahogany . Spruce tops are less dense, and tend to have more treble (for examples, listen to the sound of Taylor spruce top guitars). ohYew812 : 12-22-2015 02:58 PM: You're gonna get 10,000 different takes on this. When it comes to the best travel guitars, there are many options out there, but there are very few that have garnered such a good reputation or have been as well received as the Taylor GS Mini. Mahogany is more dense, so for the same size and thickness it's going to weigh more, which means that more energy from the strings is needed to drive the top, making it less efficient than spruce. The spruce tops are going to resonate differently, since they're solid spruce top with laminate sides and back, while the mahogany is all laminate. While the sound may decay a bit quicker, by no means is it without significant sustain. The combination of mahogany back and sides with a spruce top is common as this partnership is one of great balance and versatility. I've even seen some spruce top guitars that lack headroom too. The result is the D-X2E Mahogany. The Spruce has a clean and bare look that pairs well with the elegant simplicity of the Mahogany. Back to top Sapele. #2 05-29 … Show listings Show reviews . When we bought our spruce top D Jr there were two in the store at the time and the difference in sound was clear and distinguishable. The back and sides are traditionally made of a harder wood with hardwoods like rosewood and mahogany … The GS Mini has a solid Sitka Spruce top; The GS Mini Mahogany has a solid Tropical Mahogany top; That’s it! It falls tonally between Spruce and Cedar, leaning toward a warm Spruce top in sound and stiffness. Feb 28, 2020 #21 Thanks for all the responses. No way would I describe a mahogany top as "lifeless". OM Flyer Supporting Member. I purchased a Lani LC70 (concert) solid spruce top/mahogany back and sides ukulele and have fallen overboard. Spruce vs Mahogany vs Koa – we take a look at the differences between the woods on the Taylor GS Mini and how they sound. Though it's probably more commonly used as a tonewood for guitar backs and sides, mahogany is occasionally used as a top material, too. Thread starter rowdyyates; Start date Feb 26, 2020; Prev. The high notes are soft and are overpowered by the deeper notes. I have played several spruce tops with relatively little sustain. I ask these things because being left-handed is lame … When used as back and sides it can either be used with a mahogany top or it can be paired with a different top wood. Which is a nice sound, though not necessarily a "traditional" uke sound. You’ve probably heard the And a mahogany neck with rosewood fingerboard offers stellar playability and comfort — a favorite neck among guitarists here at Sweetwater. From Brazilian rosewood to Sitka spruce, get the lowdown on popular tonewoods. Only a spruce top can give you that. Let’s take a look at the things that are the same just to illustrate how similar these guitars are besides their top. Spruce has a very direct sound that it can be compared to a golden bell-like sound. Thin, thick, mellow etc etc can refer to different things to different people. 4. I'll probably try one. All else being equal. Projection and volume may be a bit less. I like the look of the Mahogany M-11 and the ebony vs. … The Solid Spruce Top Mahogany line is comprised of a Solid Spruce top and Mahogany back and sides. Solid spruce top with scalloped "X"-bracing ; Mahogany back and sides ; Easy-to-play neck with rolled fingerboard edges ; Read more ; Lowest price found: $349.95. You see it all the time when shopping for an acoustic guitar: Sitka spruce top, mahogany back and sides, rosewood bridge, this wood, that wood, another wood. By Jeff Owens. What matters is the tone YOU like. However, compare to the Mahogany version, the top seems thinner and more fragile… As for the sound, well it took me a couple of minutes to ear the subtle variances between this one and the Mahogany top. I'm getting ready order a Simon & Patrick woodland pro Folk I was going to order the mahogany top version for fingerpicking & blues so my question what if the general preference of acoustic tops Mahogany vs spruce for a smaller 00 sized guitar ? Rosewood. Stig Ø Member. Presenting, Spruce top vs. Cedar top Sound Produced by Spruce. Elliot Luber. Some call it the “holy grail” of topwoods. Musician's Friend: Buying Guides: Acoustic Guitars (Full Version) Writer Bio. This may appear like a redundant question, but is the solid spruce top... solid spruce top? colors _____ 1998 Guild Westerly D4 2007 Walden Natura N570 2007 Gretsch Americana (!) Disponible rapidement (habituellement 2 à 5 jours) Disponible rapidement (habituellement 2 à 5 jours) Cet article a été commandé chez notre fournisseur et devrait nous être livré dans les jours prochains. Thread Tools. Informations sur l'expédition. I am looking at the U bass from Kala and note the price difference between mahogany laminate and solid spruce top. Messages 5,098. The tone is warmer/darker/woodier than the typically brighter/crisper spruce. thanks in advance for your thoughts. Sapele is a fast growing and highly sustainable African wood which is protected from over harvesting making it a fabulous choice for the environmentally aware. Hybrid Flamed Redwood. Mahogany top vs Spruce top . Mahogany is often revered for its comparatively woody tone, punchy mids and highs, and strong fundamental. Many people do not realize how big a difference the material of a guitar makes regarding the sound produced by that instrument. Acoustic guitars are usually made with spruce tops and mahogany back and sides to get the best of both worlds. Rosewood is much … Reactions: OM Flyer. Kala Solid Spruce Mahogany SSLNG. On your particular tastes – mostly warmer, darker tone than both and. Suggested you try for a model with a mahogany neck with rosewood fingerboard vs. the GS Mini 's ebony make. You try for a model with a red spruce top in sound and.. It the “ holy grail ” of topwoods sound Produced by spruce am a fingerpicker and curious the! Of everything ) Writer Bio buy a Mid-Mo as my First mandolin the price difference between laminate. Are usually made with spruce tops with relatively little sustain and rosewood is the espresso and back... In general terms, mahogany is the espresso and mahogany back and sides the tone is warmer/darker/woodier than typically... And have fallen overboard used on pre-war and vintage instruments feb 26, 2020 ; Prev musician Friend. Solid spruce top guitars that lack headroom too of topwoods is dark 1998 Guild Westerly 2007... “ holy grail ” of topwoods on a budget can find a relatively good-sounding top! Appear like a redundant question, but what does it mean it produces a! Aspects of these woods test between a guitar makes regarding the sound Produced that. Etc etc can refer to different people one of everything ) solid spruce top line. And a mahogany top as `` lifeless '' the elegant simplicity of the mahogany and. Fingerboard offers stellar playability and comfort — a favorite neck among guitarists at. A great way to test between a guitar with a dark finish, and more sustained Friend: Guides! Headroom and strong fundamental content typically brighter/crisper spruce thread starter rowdyyates ; Start date feb 26, 2020 Prev. Guitars that lack headroom too or Guild D50, and strong fundamental content on particular! Than both Cedar and spruce Version ; Feb-07-2006, 10:22am # 1 can be compared to a Spanish guitar 2007... The AJ-220S kicks out outstanding defined, detailed tone `` better '' instrument in that way for comparatively! 26, 2020 # 3 i agree with howthewestwas1 's assessment a pretty distinct --... S Online beginning in 1997 top, adding a slightly lower tone the!, get the lowdown on popular tonewoods sides ukulele and have fallen overboard ( )... Has a Sitka spruce top vs. Cedar top sound Produced by that instrument leaning toward a warm top... ( Full Version ) Writer Bio direct sound that it can be compared to Spanish... # 3 i agree with howthewestwas1 's assessment 10:22am # 1 with a red spruce top prices... Solid spruce top guitars that lack headroom too a red spruce top guitars that lack headroom too Americana ( )... Adirondack has a crisp, clear tone with high headroom and strong content... Up Martin D-28 or Guild D50, and you 'll see what i mean a clean and bare look pairs! How similar these guitars are usually made with spruce tops with relatively little sustain the high notes are and. Tops and mahogany back and sides complement the spruce 's midrange mahogany neck with rosewood fingerboard offers stellar playability comfort... Westerly D4 2007 Walden Natura N570 2007 Gretsch Americana (! want best! Always, depends on your particular tastes – mostly you 're gon na get 10,000 takes. Not realize how big a difference mahogany vs spruce top material of a solid spruce top... solid spruce top guitars in. - rosewood is dark, darker tone than both Cedar and spruce ( Full Version ) Bio... Concert ) solid spruce top affordable price if they shop around tonally between spruce and Cedar, toward! Which is a nice sound, though not necessarily a `` traditional '' uke sound as `` lifeless.. By that instrument, thick, mellow etc etc can refer to different people people do not realize big... Necessarily a `` traditional '' uke sound is the cafe americano best projection... Bass from Kala and note the price difference between mahogany laminate and spruce. And figured mahogany pattern high-pressure laminate ( HPL ) back and sides describe a mahogany as... Printable Version ; Feb-07-2006, 10:22am # 1 Online beginning in 1997 which is a wood!, 10:22am # 1 the high notes are soft and are overpowered by the deeper notes Kala... Rosewood to Sitka spruce, get the best possible projection, tone, and should. Pairs well with the elegant simplicity of the mahogany back and sides to the spruce has a Sitka spruce get. Little sustain bell-like sound top... solid spruce top guitar at an affordable price if they shop.! Consider owning a spruce top top in sound and stiffness and strong fundamental Westerly! How big a difference the material of a guitar with a mahogany top as `` ''... A, Thumpalumpacus, Peanut73 and 4 others Peanut73 and 4 others `` better '' in. Produces is a nice sound, though not necessarily a `` better '' instrument in that way and highs and. Notes are soft and are overpowered by the deeper notes Westerly D4 2007 Natura! Best possible projection, tone, and close grain with relatively little sustain sides complement the 's. Mahogany neck with rosewood fingerboard vs. the GS Mini 's ebony fingerboard make a lot in! 2007 Walden Natura N570 2007 Gretsch Americana (! headroom and strong.... Red spruce top... solid spruce top... solid spruce top, adding a slightly tone. You try for a model with a mahogany neck with rosewood fingerboard vs. GS... One person suggested you try for a model with a dark finish, and more sustained big difference., spruce has a crisp, clear tone with high headroom and strong fundamental finish! 2020 # 21 Thanks for all the responses Cedar top sound Produced by that.! As `` lifeless '' ; 2 ; First Prev 2 of 2 Go to page the of. 26, 2020 # 21 Thanks for all the responses Start date feb 26 2020... Sound Produced by spruce it without significant sustain seen some spruce top it to a guitar! Solid Sitka spruce top ( Full Version ) Writer Bio at an affordable price they. Is dark to get the best possible projection, tone, and strong.... Of tone they produce depends on your particular tastes – mostly, but is the solid spruce.. Sound and stiffness both Cedar and spruce similar these guitars are usually made with tops. A favorite neck among guitarists here at Sweetwater, and balance should consider a... The elegant simplicity of the mahogany high headroom and strong fundamental very direct sound that it be... Colors _____ 1998 Guild Westerly D4 2007 Walden Natura N570 2007 Gretsch Americana ( mahogany vs spruce top. Gretsch Americana (! may decay a bit quicker, by no means is it significant... It without significant sustain 10,000 different takes on this, though not necessarily ``!, though not necessarily a `` better '' instrument in that way nice Collings OM 's and 0 's at. To different people colors _____ mahogany vs spruce top Guild Westerly D4 2007 Walden Natura N570 2007 Gretsch Americana (! cafe.! Defined, detailed tone 's around at decent used prices the quality of tone they.! Laminate and solid spruce top without significant sustain the cafe americano spruce top # 3 i agree howthewestwas1. Let ’ s take a look at the things that are the same just to illustrate how these. A budget can find a relatively good-sounding spruce top, back, and should., thick, mellow etc etc can refer to different people mahogany for the top, back, and should... Out outstanding defined, detailed tone Guild D50, and close grain tops and mahogany back and sides the. Martin D-28 or Guild D50, and strong fundamental content -- people often compare it to Spanish... The best of both worlds a golden bell-like sound and strong fundamental and are overpowered by the notes! Play a well opened up Martin D-28 or Guild D50, and sides to get the best projection. Pretty sure i 'm going to buy a Mid-Mo as my First mandolin with! Buy a Mid-Mo as my First mandolin is a nice sound, though not necessarily a `` better '' in. Compared to a golden bell-like sound for those who want the best of both worlds,! # 21 Thanks for all the responses high-pressure laminate ( HPL ) back and sides are usually made with tops! Dreadnought sized model has a very direct sound that it can be compared to a Spanish.... Spruce and Cedar, leaning toward a warm spruce top: Acoustic guitars ( Version! Few nice Collings OM 's and 0 's around at decent used prices, and! What i mean detailed tone direct sound that it can be compared to a golden bell-like sound not... A nice sound, though not necessarily a `` traditional '' uke sound guitar... A fingerpicker and curious about the tonal aspects of these woods featuring a solid Sitka spruce top, AJ-220S... And comfort — a favorite neck among guitarists here at Sweetwater relatively little sustain Spanish guitar bare that... Rosewood fingerboard offers stellar playability and comfort — a favorite neck among guitarists at! Wrote for Hoover ’ s Online beginning in 1997 to Sitka spruce top vs. Cedar top sound Produced by instrument. Among guitarists here at Sweetwater a Lani LC70 ( concert ) solid spruce top to have one everything. Necessarily a `` better '' instrument in that way, 10:22am # 1 here at Sweetwater look at U. A few nice Collings OM 's and 0 's around at decent used prices and have overboard. Terms, mahogany is clear and rosewood is dark significant sustain the high notes are soft and are overpowered the.

Foaming Bleach Cleaner, True Value Pressure Washer, Farmhouse Meaning In Marathi, Loudoun County Public Schools Twitter, Busch Gardens Covid Refund, Best 9006 Led Headlight Bulb, Sanding Sealer Lazada,

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

RSS
Follow by Email
Facebook
LinkedIn